I (24f) don’t know much about cars and struggle to retain information no matter how much I try! I’m looking for a new car and could use some advice.
A little about me:
I live in Minnesota (in the Twin Cities suburbs). I drive around 18,000 - 20,000 miles a year. I need a car that can comfortably fit 5-6 people. I’m also really worried about winter driving.
I’ve never bought a car before. My family has always passed down their old cars to me when they get new ones, and I’m very grateful for that. But this time, I need to make the decision myself, and I’m not sure where to start.
My first car was a 2014 Nissan Altima with FWD and no snow tires. It was awful in the winter—I felt unsafe and often lost traction. After that, I had a 2008 Lexus RX350 with 4WD. I liked being higher up, and it felt more stable in bad weather. Now, I drive a 2012 GMC Acadia with FWD and no snow tires. It’s fine, but I’ve had terrible traction, even with new tires.
Knowing that my biggest concern is snow and ice, do you think a Subaru Outback (or Forester) would be a good fit for me? If so, how old/miles can I go on a used one if I plan to keep it for 2-3 years, or longer if possible? If not, what other cars would you suggest?
Zayn said:
Outbacks and Foresters don’t fit 6 people. No matter what car you pick, make sure to get snow tires.
I live in the Twin Cities too and drive my Legacy with Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady tires. I’ve had no issues with winter driving. Minnesota road crews know how to keep the roads safe in winter.
@LandCruiserLover
I used to live on the Minnesota/Iowa border and never used snow tires. The road crews are great there. Now, I’m in Southern Idaho where even an inch of snow shuts everything down. The roads aren’t treated or plowed, and everyone has snow tires!
@LandCruiserLover
I’m another Twin Cities Subaru owner. Snow tires aren’t strictly necessary, but it’s helpful to drive sensibly. All-season tires work for me, and my cars handle snow and ice better than my friends’ FWD cars. But AWD won’t make you invincible, still need to drive carefully, especially around corners. I love my Impreza, but it only seats 5, so if you need 6, look elsewhere.
The Subaru Ascent fits your need for a larger SUV with 7-8 seats, but it’s not for everyone. The Forester would be a better fit for you. I’ve owned both.
Hey, I’m from the Twin Cities too! I drive a 2018 Outback, and it’s been great in Minnesota, Colorado, Idaho, and Montana winters. But with Subarus, don’t skip maintenance. Keep up with oil changes and CVT fluid changes!
Subarus need a lot of maintenance. If you’re okay with regular 30k mile services, then go for it. If you want longer service intervals, consider a Toyota Highlander.
Bradley said:
Subarus need a lot of maintenance. If you’re okay with regular 30k mile services, then go for it. If you want longer service intervals, consider a Toyota Highlander.
Subaru’s maintenance costs are higher compared to other brands. Here’s an article: [Link]
@Rory
It looks like you shared an AMP link. These links load faster, but they’re controversial for privacy concerns. Check out the regular page instead: [Link]
If you’re worried about winter driving, a Subaru is a solid choice. Also, you’ll need to feel comfortable with your car. Consider taking a driving course to feel more confident behind the wheel.
